News, Vision & Voice for the Advisory Community


Vestmark credits a 'tip-off' and an unlikely rocket propellant -- advertising spend -- for Adhesion's 68% asset jump in first-year under its wing

When the Wakefield, Mass., TAMP bought Adhesion in 2018, its execs cited its 'be-like-Envestnet' mindset for growing RIA marketshare

Tuesday, April 7, 2020 – 12:58 AM by Oisin Breen
no description available
Barrett Ayers: Adhesion may increase its headcount by a further 40% in the coming year, a pace of hiring that will continue for the 'foreseeable future.'

Brooke's Note: RIAs have run roughshod over asset managers for decades -- demanding better returns, more variety and better software -- all with the understanding that they get charged pennies for these improved efforts. In rare instances -- like target date funds, TAMPs and OCIOs -- asset managers claw back some ground by usurping some "RIA" turf in managing a broader portfolio. But almost all of the asset manager claw-backs happened on the IBD side to "hybrid RIAs." This story of Vestmark's success with Adhesion suggests that TAMPs are upping their games enough to bring RIAs into the fold -- or maybe RIAs are just getting word that there is an easier way.

When Vestmark bought a small RIA TAMP in 2018, it used an unlikely strategy -- big advertising -- to bring about an unlikely explosion of AUM growth -- up 68% in only two years.

Scott MacKillop
Scott MacKillop: Vestmark had visions of competing with Envestnet directly ... then they realized how hard it is.

The Wakefield, Mass., firm bought Adhesion in Oct. 2018, on the back of a "tip off" that RIAs were ready to pounce on the opportunity to outsource more investment management.

"What tipped us off was the [RIA TAMP inflows] we were seeing at all the [custodians], like Fidelity, Schwab and TD, regarding RIAs," says Lonnie MacDonald, Vestmark's chief marketing officer, via email. See: Fidelity Institutional looks like big TAMP as Mike Durbin removes last walls between products and advisors after 'meteoric' 2019 leap

"When we acquired Adhesion back in late 2018, they had a very small marketing budget. We have since increased this budget dramatically."

Accelerated growth

If Adhesion's vision holds, it could mark a watershed for RIAs. Though TAMPs have boomed for years, it has been mostly through IBD reps, who still live under FINRA oversight and use the outsourcers as a means of mimicking RIAs as fee-based fiduciary advisors.

What TAMPs like Adhesion, Envestnet and SMartX are increasingly trying to do is to bring the best of the IBD world over to RIAs by vastly simplifying the investing and reporting aspects of their businesses.

Lonnie MacDonald
Lonnie MacDonald: We’ll leave it to others to look at our growth … and determine where we stack up versus our competitors.

Vestmark's heavy spending on advertising the Charlotte-based "Adhesion" brand can be felt in the Rocky Mountains too, says Scott MacKillop, CEO of Denver TAMP, First Ascent Asset Management, via email.

"The acquisition noticeably accelerate[d] Adhesion’s growth … I see Adhesion out and about more than I did before."

Adhesion's assets under management (AUM) surged to $4.7 billion, as of Dec. 31, 2019 on the strength of adding 50 new RIA clients, taking its overall RIA count to to 150.

Chief marketing officer Lonnie MacDonald would only say “substantial assets were invested” to advertise Adhesion. The company declined to specify an exact amount. 

The stock market decline, driven by the global pandemic, has stripped 16.4% from Adhesion's 68% AUM surge, as of Mar. 20. That assumes a 60-40 split between equities and bonds, based on the S&P 500 and the Vanguard Total Bond Market Index as benchmarks.

Factoring in Covid-19 depreciation, Vestmark now administers $1.17 trillion, down from $1.4 trillion; Adhesion manages $3.9 billion.

Easy button

The gains have been substantial, but Vestmark's decision to plough hard cash into Adhesion's marketing budget wasn't just predicated on a tip-off, says MacDonald.

"[It was] a great way to fast-track our entry in to the RIA space ... [and] market research and trends also pushed us to make the acquisition."

Indeed, the decision to buy Adhesion was also motivated by the fact that the two firms run the same software. The synergy resulted in the marriage.

Adhesion overlays Vestmark's flagship portfolio management software, VestmarkOne, with its own "easy-button," RIA front. See: Vestmark calls out Envestnet as it makes 'easy-button' purchase.

This overlay, like Adhesion's marketing budget, benefited from Vestmark's largesse, after the firm paid for a Silicon Valley redesign, according to Adhesion President Barrett Ayers.

"The ongoing investment of time and resources by Vestmark in Adhesion has placed us in a strong position," he said in a release.

Baby steps

Yet Adhesion's growth is still a consolation prize, after Vestmark's earlier plays to win RIAs mostly fizzled, says MacKillop.

Evan Rapoport
Evan Rapoport: I have watched too many firms over my twenty years in fintech try to do everything with mediocrity.

"A while back Vestmark had visions of competing with  Envestnet directly because they have an industrial strength TAMP technology platform. But then they realized how hard it is to compete; it’s not just about hav[ing] the underlying technology." 

"They acquired Adhesion to get a toehold," he adds.

Chicago-based Envestnet has a chokehold  on a broader market, though it doesn't break out RIA assets where its own TAMP penetration is more nominal. See: After $30-million VC raise, Vestmark is no longer just that UBS-LPL TAMP engine in the Massachusetts suburbs.

Pre-Covid-19, Envestnet administered about $3.7 trillion, and its TAMP $182 billion, according to the firm's latest 10k filings. Factor in estimated market declines, and these figures now stand at $3.1 trillion, and $152 billion, respectively -- 2.6 times, and 39 times more, respectively, than the sums administered and managed by Vestmark and Adhesion.

Adhesion is just getting going, says MacDonald.

"We're [still] investing in Adhesion's marketing, and, as evidenced by Adhesion’s business results, it’s clear many more RIAs have heard of us. From Vestmark’s side of the shop, awareness and interest among larger RIAs, roll-ups and aggregators has increased meaningfully over the past 12 months."

Fresh spending imminent

Don't discount Vestmark's power to buy more growth by acquisition, he adds. “There’s lots of opportunities out there, [and] we’re always interested in possibilities … to deliver an improved advisor experience … [and] better outcomes for investors."

John Lunny
Vestmark CEO John Lunny signed off on the Vestmark deal as part of a bid to turn the firm into a more viable competitor with Envestnet.

Vestmark now employs 450, an increase of 106 in the last 18 months, according to data from the firm. Adhesion employs 37, up from 27 in Oct. 2018.

Adhesion also intends to increase its headcount by a further 40% in the coming year, a pace of hiring Ayers expects will continue for the "foreseeable future."

Additionally, the firm has rolled out a choose-your-own OCIO program, listing outsourced chief investment officers for hire in the same way it does investment strategies. See: The super-TAMP 'OCIO' category suddenly, finally looks mortal in 2019, says Cerulli report, but modest reinvention and price cuts could give it a new run

Since its acquisition, Adhesion has added 500 strategies and 155 new asset managers to its strategy and manager marketplace, bringing the total listed to roughly 900 and 650, respectively.

Ever the evangelists

Adhesion makes much of using UMAs (unified managed accounts), which allow RIAs to manage multiple managers as if they are one. 

But Adhesion's growth may depend on creating a broader oneness, says MacKillop.

"Adhesion sees the world a little differently ... [they're] big on touting their UMA technology [and] believe it's a competitive advantage. That gives them an edge. Personally, I think advisors ... care more about the end result than how you got there."

 The "end result" of a good TAMP comprises solid returns but also other workflow outsourcing like easy account opening and mistake-free trades,  MacKillop adds.

Downmarket threat?

Vestmark is on the attack in seeking RIA assets, but it can expect specialized rivals to exploit its broadened mission, says Evan Rapoport, CEO of West Palm Beach, Fla.,TAMP rival SMArtX, via email, in response to questions on his own firm’s recent fundraising round.

 "There are simply too many products and too many different use cases … I have watched too many firms over my 20 years in fintech try to do everything with mediocrity vs. one thing with expertise."  

SMArtX recently wooed $100 million in managed assets from Adhesion, Rapoport says. The Adhesion client was Beachwood, Ohio's, One Seven. See: After riding Black Diamond's coattails from near zero to $2 billion of AUM, SMArtX raises $4 million to compete as a 'Vestmark'-model firm.

Apples to oranges

But MacDonald bristles at the suggestion Vestmark is vulnerable to down-market rivals.

"We’ll leave it to others to look at our growth … and determine where we stack up versus our competitors."

Related Moves

Envestnet just named an ESG head to meld 'wellness,' 'The Intelligent Financial Life' and 'sustainable investing' into a single nirvana -- that starts outside of the product realm

Ron Ransom earned CEO Bill Crager's trust as chief business development officer and now will define how Envestnet conducts itself as a global citizen and vendor of wellness.

July 27, 2022 – 2:27 AM

Envestnet and Edmond Walters end odd couple 'Apprise' relationship with buyout, but leave open the door to jointly pursue RIA-to-entrepreneur dashboard... later

The MoneyGuidePro owner and eMoney founder execute clean break with Apprise IP rebranded as 'Wealth Studio.' Walters off to the races with a startup and vague promise to collaborate later.

April 6, 2021 – 12:50 AM

Envestnet turns to former FIS executive -- and replaces a CTO -- to help shape up the firm's disparate offerings into a unified whole around the concept of 'wellness'

The Chicago outsourcer gets Donna Peeples to harmonize products and marketing to move beyond the 'TAMP' label as Orion contends for market share with Brinker added.

November 10, 2020 – 2:45 AM

With $4 million VC raise fresh in hand, SMArtX takes next step to shed Black Diamond shadow by hiring a president/COO who casts his own

.Jonathan Pincus took overseen assets at Northern Trust from $3 billion to $70 billion at his Chicago firm and learned about SMartX after in his old role

May 22, 2020 – 9:36 PM

See more related moves

Mentioned in this article:

Envestnet Inc
Top Executive: Jud Bergman

Portfolio Management System
Top Executive: Michael Blundin

SMArtX Advisory Solutions
Top Executive: Evan Rapoport

Bob Lodie

Bob Lodie

April 7, 2020 — 3:11 PM
Great story of growth strategy success in the making.

RIABiz Directory

The Industry Sourcebook for RIAs

   |    LISTING

RIABiz Directory sponsored by:

Directory Sponsor Logo