News, Vision & Voice for the Advisory Community
Compliance experts and advisors throw down the gauntlet on CRM chat challenges but CEO/CTO Brian McLaughlin is unfazed
October 11, 2017 — 7:30 PM UTC by By Lisa Shidler
Brooke's Note: I am unqualified to edit this article in one important sense. I have never in my life sent a text. I am neither proud nor embarrassed about that fact. Never having texted is directly tied to my never owning a smartphone. (I'll leave that topic for another day.) But if I were a software maker for RIAs, I'd be tempted to build toward this whole texting thing. It hasn't escaped my attention that people are, like, way into it to the point of risking their lives to read and send them while operating machinery. Two things texts definitely do better than emails that should be of concern to advisors. First, they create a sense of urgency. People respond to texts on average within three minutes. When I send emails with pressing questions, sometimes it takes three days to hear back. Second, texts are much, much, much more likely to make headway with younger people. My nieces and nephews pretty much don't know what an email is. So good on Redtail for making this move. But being journalists, we made sure to talk to all the sources we could about why Brian McLaughlin still has his work cut out for him. No texts were sent in the making of this article.
Fixate instead for the moment on Redtail Technology, which quietly dominates the customer relationship management software market at 200 independent broker-dealers with 27,000 affiliated firms and 90,000 users -- with LPL Financial as its marquee client.
Redtail offers an advisor-sensitive CRM product at a low price in a way that keeps broker-dealers from getting into trouble with FINRA. See: Review: How Redtail got hot fast among RIAs and how it plans to leapfrog itself.
But now the 15-year-old Gold River, Calif.-based technology firm is expanding on an less-known aspect of itself -- a willingness to push the edge and even take modest market risks in order to keep and expand market share.
Redtail has unveiled Speak, the means by which advisors can communicate with clients on its CRM system via text rather than via email on a private server. See: VCs back Wealthbox with another $6 million as improbable play to upend CRM giants like Salesforce, Microsoft and Redtail by 'Facebooking' its look and shanghai-ing data from LinkedIn.
Observers wonder if the idea is ahead of its time -- after all, only about 10% of advisors text clients versus nearly 100% who use email.
But Redtail CEO and chief technology officer Brian McLaughlin isn't worried about following a trend -- he says his firm is a trend-maker.
"This has nothing to do with our competitors. A few years ago, we came up with a conceptual prototype (at the FUSE 2015 hackathon) and realized that only 10% of advisors text clients because they don't have a system in place to do it from a compliance standpoint. There's a huge gap and no one is stepping up to build a solution."
Redtail is charging $79 per month, or about $950 per firm, annually. Given the 27,000 firms administered by its CRM, the marginal revenue potential is about $25 million.
Rather than the 10% figure, McLaughlin is guided by statistics showing that 80% of adults text every day, with adults over 55 sending and receiving 500 texts per month.. Millennial usage, predictably, is three times greater than that. See: Salesforce discloses upcoming RIA CRM product, cryptically and to some jeers.
Also important is that Redtail found the "open" rate for texts is almost 100% whereas a third of all emails never get opened. Text messages also create a sense of urgency with response times of about three minutes.
Still, the biggest challenge for Redtail isn't texting, says Michael Kitces, co-founder of XY Planning and author of the blog Nerd's Eye View. Rather, It's the issue of advisors needing to be logged on to the CRM software via Redtail to send a text.
"The biggest caveat here is that people text message from their smartphones. Not from their computers logged into a CRM website. And so I’m not certain how efficient or practical Redtail Speak will be in this context."
In the new program, clients can send texts to advisors by using their cell phones, McLaughlin explains.
Still, Kitces says the texting needs to be mobile for both the advisor and the client.
"Basically, I don’t really view this as 'text messaging' with clients, per se. It’s using your CRM to push messages to a client’s mobile device via a text message. But it’s not quite the same use case as two-way text messaging, the way most people are accustomed to texting [directly from their mobile device’s texting apps]."
Kitces concedes that Redtail Speak works as a way for, say, a staff member to confirm a meeting time with a client. "But for an advisor running late to a meeting who wants to quickly text the client to let them know, the requirement to do so from within Redtail may be a deal-killer for practical impromptu use," he says.
And Redtail Speak has other structural impediments to contend with, says Brian Hamburger, founder of MarketCounsel, whose Englewood, N.J. firm sells compliance readiness to advisors. MarketCounsel once owned MailBanc, an email archiving software you could subscribe to for $950 a year. See: MarketCounsel's MailBanc automates away some of the liability risk of instant communications.
"'Speak' apparently allows an advisor to send chat messages to a client's mobile phone," he writes in an email. "But it's not outbound text messaging alone that advisors yearn for. Text messaging brings with it an expectation of immediate response. Integration into an advisor’s phone is the only way to replicate that experience,"
Asked whether Raleigh, N.C.-based Junxure is working to give RIAs a way to text clients via text, its president, Greg Friedman, who just spent a few days in Las Vegas with hundreds of Junxure users, responds by email: "Yes, but ZERO customers requesting…"
But there's also a question of whether clients truly are clamoring for texting capabilities.
And Hamburger says that adding texting to CRM is not a straightforward engineering task.
"The elusive solution combines an advisor’s mobile device with an SMS client that’s captured side-by-side with the advisor’s email archiving solution as well as the capability to make that available for those advisor’s that the firm chooses to have that level of instantaneous access," he says.
"It seems that Redtail is on the hunt for that solution and may very have come closer than any of their peers to date."
McLaughlin says Redtail has plans for traditional texting via smart phones. But he says the reason this program was created via the CRM is so an entire firm could use it and not just one advisor. Right now, an advisor texts via the CRM system but clients can text via a traditional smartphone.
"It’s a collaborative platform allow and as such our initial launch is targeted at Redtail CRM users," he says. "It uses the CRM as the platform for firms to message their clients. Advisors and staff can receive text notifications on their phones when clients message them." See: Addepar deal may salve big, lingering pain point for RIAs who use alternative investments.
Redtail intends to release another application where advisors can text from their smartphones.
"Soon we will release the Speak companion mobile app allow advisors and their staff text on the run," McLaughlin writes in an email.
The net impact of Speak can not be overstated, says Joel Bruckenstein, founder of the popular T3 Conference, and who reviewed the product.
"This is a really big deal. Others will try and copy what they've done but they're the first to do it. They're one of the most popular software used by advisors. If it was an obscure CRM company it would be a big deal but Redtail is one of the leading CRMs in the industry."
All CRMs will have to reckon with numerous compliance concerns concerning texting. FINRA has a new rule that requires all text message conversations be preserved. This FINRA attention to texts has chilled the enthusiasm of other would-be pioneers.
Orion Advisor Services LLC of Omaha, Neb. has a text-bot called Orion Notifications which it rolled out a year ago, but what Redtail is offering is quite different, acknowledges Eric Clarke, CEO of Orion. See: Eric Clarke rolls the API dice by posting Orion software's code online.
"What Redtail is doing allows the advisor to engage in conversation via text message, which is an industry first that I am aware of. Pretty exciting stuff," he says.
Right now, Orion's program allows advisors to send command texts such as "TRAN" for recent transactions or "APPT" to remind clients to schedule an appointment with the advisor.
Quick and easy
McLaughlin is convinced his company's new text program is different than anything the competition currently offers, including San Francisco-based Salesforce.
"We believe it's a game-changing solution for advisors and something they're doing every day but they don't have a solution in place to text clients. No one is offering advisors best practices for texting clients. It doesn't exist."
In his review of Redtail Speak, Bruckenstein offers details about technical aspects. Clients get to opt out or opt in, a decision which gets recoded. Hashtags can be applied to multi-user chats. Chat archives can be fed into compliance tools. Speak has voice recognition.
And someday the voice aspect may be extended to clients.
Mentioned in this article:
Top Executive: Brian McLaughlin
Consulting Firm, Specialized Breakaway Service, Compliance Expert
Top Executive: Brian Hamburger
Technology Tools for Today
Top Executive: Joel Bruckenstein
Top Executive: Michael Kitces
Top Executive: Greg Friedman
Share your thoughts and opinions with the author or other readers.